
Well, butter my biscuit, slap a bow on a felony, and somebody fetch Magnolia her smelling salts, because apparently the Waco justice system has opened itself a brand-new LEAST-WAYS-YOU-PAID-IT-BACK REWARDS PROGRAM!
Honey, I have seen some mighty peculiar things in McLennan County, but this one deserves its own float in the Homecoming Parade of Judicial Nonsense.
Now, let me see if Magnolia has this straight.
Andress Sellman was already on felony deferred probation in Falls County after a case involving $130,000 taken from a 68-year-old widow who hired her to build a home.
Then along comes another case involving a couple who trusted her not only as their contractor, but as their FRIEND.
And according to investigators, money intended to build somebodyās dream home was instead spent on clothing, vehicle expenses, hair care, vacations, and other personal purchases.
WELL, HALLELUJAH AND PASS THE CREDIT CARD!
Apparently, the foundation wasnāt getting poured, but somebodyās lifestyle was getting financed!
Now, honey, I understand construction. I understand draws, materials, subcontractors, and the difference between a legitimate business expense and a personal shopping spree.
And I can assure you, a family vacation is NOT a line item under concrete, framing, or plumbing!
But donāt yāall worry your sweet little heads.
Because here comes the McLennan County District Attorneyās Office with a plea recommendation, and Judge Thomas West with another helping of that famous courthouse hospitality.
FIVE YEARS OF DEFERRED PROBATION!
Thatās right, sugar. Not a prison sentence. Not even a final judgment of guilt if she successfully completes her deferred adjudication.
Just another opportunity to straighten up and fly right.
And as an added precaution, Judge West prohibited her from working in the construction industry in a fiduciary capacity.
WELL, THANK THE GOOD LORD!
Nothing says protecting the public quite like telling somebody who has already been involved in multiple construction-related theft cases that she canāt handle other peopleās construction money anymore.
Magnolia would have thought that particular lesson might have been learned somewhere around the FIRST $130,000.
But apparently, Iām just old-fashioned.
And then thereās the restitution.
Now, honey, Iām glad those victims got their money back. Every single penny they recovered matters.
But since when did PAYING BACK MONEY YOU WRONGFULLY TOOK become the courthouse equivalent of a get-out-of-jail-free card?
If a fellow steals a pickup truck, drives it around for six months, and brings it back washed and waxed, does the judge hand him a thank-you note and a coupon for his next oil change?
If somebody empties Grandmaās bank account and returns the money after getting caught, are we supposed to throw a parade?
IS THIS CRIMINAL JUSTICE OR A RENT-TO-OWN PROGRAM FOR OTHER PEOPLEāS MONEY?
And letās not overlook the attorney.
Former McLennan County District Attorney Abel Reyna represented Sellman and announced that he was pleased with the favorable resolution.
Well, of course he was, darlinā.
His client got probation, the victims got restitution, and everybody gets to move forward.
Except perhaps the people who spent months wondering whether their homes would ever be built, their money would ever be recovered, or their trust in another human being would ever be restored.
But apparently those little inconveniences donāt fit neatly into a plea agreement.
And Judge Thomas West even admonished Sellman to pay attention while one of her victims described the devastation.
OH, LORD, NOT A STERN TALKING-TO!
Somebody fetch the fainting couch!
Nothing strikes fear into the heart of a convictedāor in this case, deferred-adjudicationādefendant quite like being told to LISTEN CAREFULLY.
Now, before somebody gets their judicial robes in a wad, Magnolia understands that deferred adjudication is legal. Restitution is important. Plea bargains are part of the system.
But what Magnolia would dearly love to understand is HOW MANY TIMES DOES SOMEBODY GET TO DO THIS BEFORE THE COURTHOUSE DECIDES THAT PROBATION ALONE MAY NOT BE ENOUGH?
Weāre talking about a widow.
A family building its forever home.
Friendships betrayed.
Vendors who had to be repaid.
And multiple criminal cases resolved without prison time.
So, Judge West and the McLennan County District Attorneyās Office, Magnolia has a few questions:
- What specifically justified recommending another deferred-adjudication sentence when Sellman had already received felony probation in Falls County?
- How much weight was given to the number of victims and the repeated nature of the conduct?
- Would an ordinary defendant with the same record and circumstances have received the same recommendation?
- Did the victims agree with the proposed punishment, or were they simply relieved to recover their money?
- And most importantly, WHEN DID RESTITUTION START LOOKING LIKE A SUBSTITUTE FOR ACCOUNTABILITY INSTEAD OF ONE PART OF IT?
Because, sweetheart, thereās a mighty big difference between making victims financially whole and making someone answer for what they did.
And one more thing.
Harry mentioned looks.
Now, Magnolia doesnāt know whether being pretty had one blessed thing to do with this outcome, and I certainly wouldnāt claim it did without evidence.
But I will say this:
JUSTICE IS SUPPOSED TO BE BLIND, NOT IMPRESSED BY A GOOD HAIR APPOINTMENT, A NICE OUTFIT, OR THE ABILITY TO WRITE A RESTITUTION CHECK.
In McLennan County, we keep hearing about accountability, law and order, and protecting hardworking citizens.
Well, sugar, those hardworking citizens include widows, families, and small-business vendors who shouldnāt have to finance somebody elseās lifestyle while waiting for their own homes and bills to be taken care of.
And if paying people back after criminal charges are filed is enough to keep securing probation, then maybe the courthouse ought to hang a new sign over the front door:
WELCOME TO WACO!
WHERE THE MONEY CAN GO MISSING, THE DREAM HOME CAN GO UNBUILT, AND THE PUNISHMENT MAY BE JUST FIVE YEARS OF BEING TOLD TO BEHAVE YOURSELF!
Bless their hearts.
Magnolia is beginning to think the only thing harder to find than an honest contractor in this particular story is a courthouse willing to explain why another round of probation was the appropriate punishment.
And honey, if that aināt worth a full-blown Southern hissy fit, I donāt know what is.
ā Magnolia šø